| Tin Soldier (2025)As Emmanuel Ashburn | (Not seen) |
| The Alto Knights (2025)As Vito Genovese / Frank Costello | (Not seen) |
| Ezra (2023)As Stan Bernal | (Not seen) |
| Albert Brooks: Defending My Life (2023)As Self | (Not seen) |
| About My Father (2023)As Salvo | (Not seen) |
| Killers of the Flower Moon (2023)As William Hale | (Not seen) |
| Amsterdam (2022)As Gil | (Not seen) |
| The War with Grandpa (2020)As Ed | (Not seen) |
| The Comeback Trail (2020)As Max Barber | (Not seen) |
| The Irishman (2019)As Frank Sheeran | (Not seen) |
| Joker (2019)As Murray Franklin | (Not seen) |
| Jim Norton: Mouthful of Shame (2017)As Himself (Uncredited) | (Not seen) |
| The Intern (2015)As Ben | (Not seen) |
| Joy (2015)As Rudy | (Not seen) |
| Heist (2015) (AKA "Bus 657")As The Pope | (Not seen) |
| The Bag Man (2014)As Dragna | (Not seen) |
| The Big Wedding (2013)As Don Griffin | (Not seen) |
| The Family (2013) (AKA "Malavita")As Fred Blake / Giovanni Manzoni | (Not seen) |
| Grudge Match (2013) (AKA "Revenge Match")As Billy 'The Kid' McDonnen | (Not seen) |
| Last Vegas (2013)As Paddy | (Not seen) |
| American Hustle (2013)As Victor Tellegio | (Not seen) |
| Killing Season (2013)As Benjamin Ford | (Not seen) |
| Freelancers (2012)As Sarcone | (Not seen) |
| Silver Linings Playbook (2012)As Pat Solatano Sr. | (Not seen) |
| Red Lights (2012)As Simon Silver | (Not seen) |
| New Year's Eve (2011)As Stan Harris | (Not seen) |
| Killer Elite (2011)As Hunter | (Not seen) |
| Limitless (2011)As Carl Van Loon | (Not seen) |
| Little Fockers (2010)As Jack Byrnes | (Not seen) |
| Stone (2010)As Jack | (Not seen) |
| Machete (2010)As Senator John McLaughlin | (Not seen) |
| Everybody's Fine (2009)As Frank Goode | (Not seen) |
| The Beaches of Agnès (2008) (AKA "Les plages d'Agnes")As Self | (Not seen) |
| What Just Happened (2008)As Ben | (Not seen) |
| Righteous Kill (2008)As Turk | (Not seen) |
| Stardust (2007)As Captain Shakespeare | (Not seen) |
| Arthur and the Invisibles (2006)As King (voice) | (Not seen) |
| The Good Shepherd (2006)As Bill Sullivan | (Not seen) |
| Hide and Seek (2005)As David Callaway | (Not seen) |
| The Bridge of San Luis Rey (2004)As Archbishop of Peru | (Not seen) |
| Meet the Fockers (2004) (AKA "Meet the Fokkers")As Jack Byrnes | (Not seen) |
| Shark Tale (2004)As Don Lino (voice) | (Not seen) |
| Fahrenheit 9/11 (2004) (AKA "Fahrenheit 911")As Self (archive footage) (uncredited) | (Not seen) |
| Godsend (2004) (AKA "Adam")As Richard Wells | (Not seen) |
| Easy Riders, Raging Bulls: How the Sex, Drugs and Rock 'N' Roll Generation Saved Hollywood (2003) (AKA "Easy Riders, Raging Bulls: How the Sex 'n' Drugs 'n' Rock 'n' Roll Generation Saved Hollywood") | (Not seen) |
| City by the Sea (2002) (AKA "Mark of a Murderer")As Vincent LaMarca | (Not seen) |
| Analyze That (2002) (AKA "Analyze You")As Paul Vitti | (Not seen) |
| Showtime (2002)As Det. Mitch Preston | (Not seen) |
| The Score (2001)As Nick Wells | (Not seen) |
| 15 Minutes (2001)As Detective Eddie Flemming | (Not seen) |
| The Adventures of Rocky & Bullwinkle (2000)As Fearless Leader | (Not seen) |
| Men of Honor (2000) (AKA "Men of Honour")As Master Chief Leslie W. Sunday ('Billy') | (Not seen) |
| Meet the Parents (2000)As Jack Byrnes | (Not seen) |
| Flawless (1999)As Walt Koontz | (Not seen) |
| Analyze This (1999) (AKA "Analyze Me")As Paul Vitti | (Not seen) |
| Great Expectations (1998)As Prisoner / Lustig | (Not seen) |
| Ronin (1998)As Sam | (Not seen) |
| Cop Land (1997) (AKA "CopLand")As Lt. Moe Tilden | (Not seen) |
| Jackie Brown (1997) (AKA "Rum Punch")As Louis Gara | (Not seen) |
| Wag the Dog (1997) (AKA "Bite the Bullet")As Conrad Brean | (Not seen) |
| Marvin's Room (1996) (AKA "My Room")As Wallace "Wally" Carter | (Not seen) |
| Sleepers (1996)As Father Bobby | (Not seen) |
| The Fan (1996)As Gil Renard | (Not seen) |
| Casino (1995)As Sam 'Ace' Rothstein | (Not seen) |
| Heat (1995)As Neil McCauley | (Not seen) |
| Frankenstein (1994) (AKA "Mary Shelley's Frankenstein")As The Creature / Sharp Featured Man | (Not seen) |
| A Bronx Tale (1993)As Lorenzo Anello | (Not seen) |
| This Boy's Life (1993) (AKA "This Boy’s Life")As Dwight Hansen | (Not seen) |
| Mad Dog and Glory (1993)As Wayne 'Mad Dog' Dobie | (Not seen) |
| Night and the City (1992)As Harry Fabian | (Not seen) |
| Hearts of Darkness: A Filmmaker's Apocalypse (1991) | (Not seen) |
| Guilty by Suspicion (1991)As David Merrill | (Not seen) |
| Backdraft (1991)As Donald Rimgale | (Not seen) |
| Cape Fear (1991)As Max Cady | (Not seen) |
| Stanley & Iris (1990)As Stanley Everett Cox | (Not seen) |
| Awakenings (1990)As Leonard Lowe | (Not seen) |
| Goodfellas (1990) (AKA "Good Fellas")As James Conway | (Not seen) |
| Jacknife (1989)As Joseph 'Jacknife' Megessey | (Not seen) |
| We're No Angels (1989)As Ned | (Not seen) |
| Midnight Run (1988)As Jack Walsh | (Not seen) |
| Angel Heart (1987)As Louis Cyphre | (Not seen) |
| The Untouchables (1987)As Al Capone | (Not seen) |
| The Mission (1986)As Rodrigo Mendoza | (Not seen) |
| Brazil (1985) (AKA "1984 and 1/2")As Archibald 'Harry' Tuttle | (Not seen) |
| Once Upon a Time in America (1984) (AKA "C'era una volta in America")As David 'Noodles' Aaronson | (Not seen) |
| The King of Comedy (1982)As Rupert Pupkin | (Not seen) |
| True Confessions (1981)As Father Des Spellacy | (Not seen) |
| Raging Bull (1980)As Jake LaMotta | (Not seen) |
| The Deer Hunter (1978) (AKA "The Man Who Came to Play")As Michael Vronsky | (Not seen) |
| Fragrance of Wild Flowers (1977) (AKA "The Fragrance of Wild Flowers") | (Not seen) |
| New York, New York (1977)As Jimmy Doyle | (Not seen) |
| The Last Tycoon (1976)As Monroe Stahr | (Not seen) |
| 1900 (1976)As Alfredo Berlinghieri | (Not seen) |
| Taxi Driver (1976)As Travis Bickle | (Not seen) |
| The Godfather Part II (1974) (AKA "Mario Puzo's The Godfather: Part II")As Don Vito Corleone | (Not seen) |
| Bang the Drum Slowly (1973)As Bruce Pearson | (Not seen) |
| Mean Streets (1973) (AKA "Season of the Witch")As John 'Johnny Boy' Civello | (Not seen) |
| Hi, Mom! (1970)As Jon Rubin | (Not seen) |
| Bloody Mama (1970)As Lloyd Barker | (Not seen) |