| movie | Maintenance Required (2025)As Mr Miller | (Not seen) |
| movie | SNL50: The Homecoming Concert (2025) | (Not seen) |
| movie | An Almost Christmas Story (2024)As Papa Owl (voice) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Greedy People (2024)As The Irishman | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Roast of Tom Brady (2024) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Unfrosted (2024)As Edsel Kellogg III | (Not seen) |
| tv | Full Circle (2023)As Manny Broward(6 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Peter Pan & Wendy (2023)As Mr. Smee | (Not seen) |
| movie | Hotel Transylvania 4: Transformania (2022) (AKA "Hotel Transylvania: Transformania")As Van Helsing (voice) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Luca (2021)As Lorenzo Paguro (voice) | (Not seen) |
| tv | DC's Stargirl (2020)As The Thunderbolt (voice)(2 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Tesla (2020)As George Westinghouse | (Not seen) |
| movie | Most Wanted (2020) (AKA "Target Number One")As Picker | (Not seen) |
| movie | Super Troopers 2 (2018)As Larry Johnson | (Not seen) |
| movie | Hotel Transylvania 3: Summer Vacation (2018)As Professor Abraham Van Helsing (voice) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Chappaquiddick (2017)As Paul Markham | (Not seen) |
| tv | The Jim Gaffigan Show (2015)As Jim Gaffigan(23 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| tv | The Late Show with Stephen Colbert (2015)As Self - Guest(6 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Hot Ones (2015)As Self(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt (2015)As Officer Krupke(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Staten Island Summer (2015)As Danny's Dad | (Not seen) |
| movie | Experimenter (2015)As James McDonough | (Not seen) |
| movie | Hot Pursuit (2015)As Red | (Not seen) |
| movie | Walter (2015)As Corey | (Not seen) |
| tv | The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon (2014)As Self(5 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Late Night with Seth Meyers (2014)As Self(5 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Rick and Morty (2013)As Hoovy (voice)(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee (2012)As Self(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Jim Gaffigan: Mr. Universe (2012)As Himself | (Not seen) |
| tv | Portlandia (2011)As Donald(2 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Bob's Burgers (2011)As Henry Haber (voice)(7 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Salvation Boulevard (2011)As Jerry Hobson | (Not seen) |
| movie | Going the Distance (2010)As Phil Berlin | (Not seen) |
| movie | It's Kind of a Funny Story (2010)As George Gilner | (Not seen) |
| movie | Away We Go (2009)As Lowell | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Slammin' Salmon (2009)As Stanley Bellin | (Not seen) |
| movie | 17 Again (2009) (AKA "17")As Coach Murphy | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Love Guru (2008)As Trent Lueders | (Not seen) |
| tv | Flight of the Conchords (2007)As Jim(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| movie | 13 Going on 30 (2004) (AKA "Suddenly 30")As Chris Grandy | (Not seen) |
| tv | Real Time with Bill Maher (2003)As Self(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Igby Goes Down (2002)As Hilton Manager | (Not seen) |
| movie | Super Troopers (2001) (AKA "Broken Lizard's Super Troopers")As Larry Johnson | (Not seen) |
| tv | Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999)As Oliver Tunney(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Three Kings (1999) (AKA "Spoils of War")As Cuts Troy's Cuff Soldier | (Not seen) |
| tv | That '70s Show (1998)As Roy(7 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Law & Order (1990)As Larry Johnson(2 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Saturday Night Live (1975)As Self - Cameo (uncredited)(5 episodes) | (Not seen) |