| tv | Superpowered: The DC Story (2023)As Self (archive footage)(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| tv | White House Plumbers (2023)As Bob Woodward (voice) (uncredited)(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Dark Winds (2022)As Robert (uncredited)(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Messiah (2020)As Narrator (voice) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Avengers: Endgame (2019)As Alexander Pierce | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Old Man & the Gun (2018)As Forrest Tucker | (Not seen) |
| movie | Earth: One Amazing Day (2017)As Narrator (voice) | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Discovery (2017)As Dr. Thomas Harbor | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Meyerowitz Stories (2017) (AKA "The Meyerowitz Stories (New and Selected)") | (Not seen) |
| movie | Pete's Dragon (2016)As Mr. Meacham | (Not seen) |
| movie | A Walk in the Woods (2015)As Bill Bryson | (Not seen) |
| movie | Marvel Studios: Assembling a Universe (2014)As Self | (Not seen) |
| movie | Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014) (AKA "Marvel Captain America: The Winter Soldier")As Alexander Pierce | (Not seen) |
| movie | All Is Lost (2013)As Our Man | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Company You Keep (2012)As Jim Grant | (Not seen) |
| movie | Lions for Lambs (2007)As Dr. Stephen Malley | (Not seen) |
| movie | Charlotte's Web (2006)As Ike the Horse (voice) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Trudell (2005)As Self | (Not seen) |
| movie | An Unfinished Life (2005) (AKA "Ein ungezahmtes Leben")As Einar Gilkyson | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Clearing (2004) (AKA "Anatomie einer Entfuhrung")As Wayne Hayes | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Last Castle (2001) (AKA "The Castle")As Lt. Gen. Eugene Irwin | (Not seen) |
| movie | Spy Game (2001) (AKA "Spy Game - Der finale Countdown")As Nathan D. Muir | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Horse Whisperer (1998)As Tom Booker | (Not seen) |
| movie | Up Close & Personal (1996)As Warren Justice | (Not seen) |
| movie | Indecent Proposal (1993)As John Gage | (Not seen) |
| movie | A River Runs Through It (1992)As Narrator (Uncredited) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Sneakers (1992)As Martin 'Marty' Bishop | (Not seen) |
| movie | Legal Eagles (1986)As Tom Logan | (Not seen) |
| movie | Out of Africa (1985)As Denys George Finch Hatton | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Natural (1984)As Roy Hobbs | (Not seen) |
| movie | Brubaker (1980)As Henry Brubaker | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Electric Horseman (1979)As Norman 'Sonny' Steele | (Not seen) |
| movie | A Bridge Too Far (1977)As Maj. Julian Cook | (Not seen) |
| movie | All the President's Men (1976)As Bob Woodward | (Not seen) |
| movie | Three Days of the Condor (1975) (AKA "3 Days of the Condor")As Joseph Turner | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Great Gatsby (1974)As Jay Gatsby | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Way We Were (1973)As Hubbell Gardner | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Sting (1973)As Johnny Hooker | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Candidate (1972)As Bill McKay | (Not seen) |
| movie | Jeremiah Johnson (1972)As Jeremiah Johnson | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Hot Rock (1972) (AKA "How to Steal a Diamond")As Dortmunder | (Not seen) |
| movie | Little Fauss and Big Halsy (1970)As Big Halsy | (Not seen) |
| movie | Tell Them Willie Boy Is Here (1969)As Deputy Sheriff Christopher 'Coop' Cooper | (Not seen) |
| movie | Downhill Racer (1969)As David Chappellet | (Not seen) |
| movie | Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969)As Sundance Kid | (Not seen) |
| movie | Barefoot in the Park (1967)As Paul Bratter | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Chase (1966)As Charlie 'Bubber' Reeves | (Not seen) |
| movie | Inside Daisy Clover (1965)As Wade Lewis / Lewis Wade | (Not seen) |
| movie | War Hunt (1962)As Pvt. Roy Loomis | (Not seen) |
| tv | The Twilight Zone (1959)As Harold Beldon(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| tv | The Oscars (1953)As Self(1 episode) | (Not seen) |