| tv | Extrapolations (2023)As Nic(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse (2023)As Peter Parker / Spider-Man (archive footage) (uncredited) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Babylon (2022)As James McKay | (Not seen) |
| movie | Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021)As Peter Parker / Spider-Man | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Boss Baby (2017)As Narrator / Older Tim Templeton (voice) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Pawn Sacrifice (2014)As Bobby Fischer | (Not seen) |
| movie | Labor Day (2013)As Older Henry Wheeler | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Great Gatsby (2013)As Nick Carraway | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Details (2011)As Jeff | (Not seen) |
| movie | Brothers (2009)As Sam Cahill | (Not seen) |
| movie | Tropic Thunder (2008)As Tobey Maguire | (Not seen) |
| movie | Spider-Man 3 (2007) (AKA "Spider-Man 3: The IMAX Experience")As Peter Parker / Spider-Man | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Good German (2006)As Tully | (Not seen) |
| movie | Spider-Man 2 (2004) (AKA "Spider-Man 2 Lives")As Peter Parker / Spider-Man | (Not seen) |
| movie | Seabiscuit (2003)As Red Pollard | (Not seen) |
| movie | Spider-Man (2002) (AKA "Spider-Man: The Motion Picture")As Peter Parker / Spider-Man | (Not seen) |
| movie | Don's Plum (2001)As Ian | (Not seen) |
| movie | Cats & Dogs (2001)As Lou the Beagle (voice) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Wonder Boys (2000)As James Leer | (Not seen) |
| movie | Ride with the Devil (1999)As Jake Roedel | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Cider House Rules (1999)As Homer Wells | (Not seen) |
| movie | Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas (1998)As Hitchhiker | (Not seen) |
| movie | Pleasantville (1998)As David | (Not seen) |
| movie | Joyride (1997)As J.T. | (Not seen) |
| movie | Deconstructing Harry (1997) (AKA "The Meanest Man in the World")As Harvey Stern/Harry's Character | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Ice Storm (1997)As Paul Hood | (Not seen) |
| tv | The Daily Show (1996)As Self(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Empire Records (1995) (AKA "Empire") | (Not seen) |
| movie | S.F.W. (1994)As Al | (Not seen) |
| movie | This Boy's Life (1993) (AKA "This Boy’s Life")As Chuck Bolger | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Wizard (1989)As Lucas' Goon at Video Armageddon (uncredited) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Roseanne (1988)(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| tv | Saturday Night Live (1975)As Self - Host(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| tv | The Oscars (1953)As Self(3 episodes) | (Not seen) |