| movie | Dead Man's Wire (2025)As M.L. Hall | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Ritual (2025)As Father Theophilus Riesinger | (Not seen) |
| movie | How to Rob a Bank (2024)As Lt. Vincent Hanna (archive footage) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Sly (2023)As Self (archive footage) (uncredited) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Knox Goes Away (2023)As Xavier Crane | (Not seen) |
| movie | House of Gucci (2021)As Aldo Gucci | (Not seen) |
| tv | Hunters (2020)As Meyer Offerman / Wilhelm Zuchs(18 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Irishman (2019)As Jimmy Hoffa | (Not seen) |
| movie | Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood (2019) (AKA "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood")As Marvin Schwarz | (Not seen) |
| movie | Spielberg (2017) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Hangman (2017)As Detective Archer | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Pirates of Somalia (2017)As Seymour Tolbin | (Not seen) |
| movie | Misconduct (2016)As Charles Abrams | (Not seen) |
| movie | Danny Collins (2015)As Danny Collins | (Not seen) |
| tv | The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon (2014)As Self(1 episode) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Phil Spector (2013)As Phil Spector | (Not seen) |
| movie | Despicable Me 2 (2013)As Eduardo / El Macho (voice) (uncredited) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Stand Up Guys (2012)As Valentine "Val" | (Not seen) |
| movie | Jack and Jill (2011)As Self | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Son of No One (2011)As Detective Stanford | (Not seen) |
| movie | You Don't Know Jack (2010)As Dr. Jack Kevorkian | (Not seen) |
| movie | Righteous Kill (2008)As Rooster | (Not seen) |
| movie | Ocean's Thirteen (2007) (AKA "13")As Willy Bank | (Not seen) |
| movie | 88 Minutes (2007)As Jack Gramm | (Not seen) |
| movie | Two for the Money (2005) (AKA "For the Money")As Walter Abrams | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Merchant of Venice (2004) (AKA "William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice")As Shylock | (Not seen) |
| tv | Angels in America (2003)As Roy Cohn(6 episodes) | (Not seen) |
| movie | Gigli (2003) (AKA "Tough Love")As Starkman | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Recruit (2003) (AKA "The Farm")As Walter Burke | (Not seen) |
| movie | People I Know (2002)As Eli Wurman | (Not seen) |
| movie | S1m0ne (2002) (AKA "Simone")As Viktor Taransky | (Not seen) |
| movie | Insomnia (2002)As Will Dormer | (Not seen) |
| movie | Tough Guise: Violence, Media & the Crisis in Masculinity (1999)As Self | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Insider (1999) (AKA "60 Minutes")As Lowell Bergman | (Not seen) |
| movie | Any Given Sunday (1999) (AKA "Gridiron")As Tony D'Amato | (Not seen) |
| movie | Donnie Brasco (1997)As Benjamin 'Lefty' Ruggiero | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Devil's Advocate (1997) (AKA "Devil's Advocate")As John Milton | (Not seen) |
| movie | Looking for Richard (1996)As Himself/Richard III | (Not seen) |
| movie | City Hall (1996)As Mayor John Pappas | (Not seen) |
| movie | Heat (1995)As Lt. Vincent Hanna | (Not seen) |
| movie | Carlito's Way (1993)As Carlito Brigante | (Not seen) |
| movie | Glengarry Glen Ross (1992)As Richard 'Ricky' Roma | (Not seen) |
| movie | Scent of a Woman (1992)As Lieutenant Colonel Frank Slade | (Not seen) |
| movie | Frankie and Johnny (1991) (AKA "Frankie & Johnny")As Johnny | (Not seen) |
| movie | Madonna: Truth or Dare (1991)As Self | (Not seen) |
| movie | Dick Tracy (1990)As Big Boy Caprice | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Godfather Part III (1990) (AKA "Mario Puzo's The Godfather: Part III")As Don Michael Corleone | (Not seen) |
| movie | Sea of Love (1989)As Frank Keller | (Not seen) |
| movie | Revolution (1985) (AKA "Revolution 1776")As Tom Dobb | (Not seen) |
| movie | Scarface (1983)As Antonio "Tony" Montana | (Not seen) |
| movie | Cruising (1980)As Steve Burns | (Not seen) |
| movie | And Justice for All (1979) (AKA "...And Justice for All")As Arthur Kirkland | (Not seen) |
| movie | Bobby Deerfield (1977)As Bobby | (Not seen) |
| movie | Dog Day Afternoon (1975)As Sonny Wortzik | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Godfather Part II (1974) (AKA "Mario Puzo's The Godfather: Part II")As Don Michael Corleone | (Not seen) |
| movie | Serpico (1973)As Officer Frank Serpico | (Not seen) |
| movie | Scarecrow (1973)As Francis Lionel 'Lion' Delbuchi | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Godfather (1972) (AKA "Mario Puzo's The Godfather")As Michael Corleone | (Not seen) |
| movie | The Panic in Needle Park (1971)As Bobby | (Not seen) |
| tv | The Oscars (1953)As Self(8 episodes) | (Not seen) |